logo en full

Research

The aim of the project is to better understand the processes undergoing during a traditional cognitive training and to compare them with analogous processes happening during a modern method of cognitive training, i.e. video gaming.

 

RESEARCH PROJECT

To train or to play?


A comparison of traditional and gamified training approaches: The role of psychophysiological, cognitive and motivational factors in the improvement of executive functions.

 

Research Unit
UNI SWPS english
Grant Amount
897 205 PLN
Funding Source
NCN logo poziom en2

Duration of Research Project: 2014-2017

 

 

The aim of the project is to better understand the processes undergoing during a traditional cognitive training and to compare them with analogous processes happening during a modern method of cognitive training, i.e. video gaming. The research project will enhance the understanding of cognitive, motivational and psychophysiological processes facilitating improvement of performance. Most likely, the project will result in the creation of empirically based recommendations for developers of training paradigms.

Research objectives

This project proposes to address a deficit of basic research in the field of cognitive training. Cognitive training is present in the literature in primarily two forms: working memory training and video game training.  

Working memory training uses tasks such as the N-back paradigm in order to train basic executive functions in an effort to indirectly improve fluid intelligence.  Video game training uses popular video games to train a broad range of cognitive functions centered on visual attention.  While studies in these fields have shown that the improvement of cognitive functions through training is possible, the motivational, cognitive, and psychophysiological factors underlying this process are relatively unknown.  Without such knowledge we are relegated to the role of observer, and progress leading to a global understanding of how to improve cognitive functioning through training will remain in the largely stagnant state that it currently finds itself in. Such an assertion is supported by the fact that studies in both fields struggle to show consistent results and explain the results that are obtained:  working memory training often fails to find performance increases past the trained ability itself, while video game training inconsistently produces performance increases in a wide range of cognitive abilities.  

Cognitive training research has thus far been focused on the presentation of effects as opposed to the understanding of their occurrence.  Although this trend is beginning to move back towards basic research, to date no comprehensive attempt has been made to study the psychological or psychophysiological factors leading to cognitive enhancement.  This project intends to do just that, and will do so through a series of tightly controlled training studies using both working memory and video game approaches to train executive functions.  

By manipulating motivational factors and monitoring the theoretically plausible mediators (psychological and psychophysiological) of successful cognitive training, we hope to lay the groundwork for future research into how we can optimize such trainings instead of simply conducting them.

Researchers

 

259 Roman Cieslak

Associate Professor

Aneta Brzezicka

Principal Investigator
Psychologist, specilizing in research methodology and cognitive neuroscience
abrzezi2@swps.edu.pl

Research project methodology

Two series of studies will be conducted in this project.

Study I and following data analysis will be directed at identifying key behavioral, motivational, and psychophysiological factors of cognitive change observed in the context of working memory training versus its “gamified” version. In order to study the significance of motivation we will manipulate the training scenario by introducing video game features into the dual N-back task, creating an enriched version to compare with the original. The remaining factors – behavioral and psychophysiological – will be measured during pre and post training measurement sessions.

Study II will employ the same methodology (dependent and mediating/moderating variables) to compare two version of a video game in order to identify behavioral and psychophysiological factors leading to cognitive improvement after exposure to video games. Motivational factors will also be manipulated here by assigning participants to single or multiplayer versions of the game. The dependent and mediating variables will be identical in both studies, giving us the opportunity to precisely establish the mechanisms underlying observed improvement in each paradigm (training and gaming) and to assess motivational factors in each training regime.

Expected impact of the research project on the development of science, civilization and society

Answering the basic questions identified by this project falls in line with the logical progression of cognitive training research and is therefore a justifiable effort to address highly salient scientific problems present within the field. Furthermore, while current efforts are beginning to move in the direction of this type of basic research, the consolidated approach proposed by this project is unique in the sense that no such attempt to synthesize knowledge from two parallel (but separate) fields has to date been made.

It would be the first training study of its kind, and the results could potentially serve as a catalyst for further research. As this project aims to improve our understanding of what makes for a successful cognitive training intervention, the potential impact is significant. Improved cognition is not only relevant to the average person looking for a brain boost, as the ability to increase the performance of key cognitive functions may have great implications for attempts at neurorehabilitation.

Patients with impaired cognitive functioning, whether it is trauma or disorder related, may stand to benefit from efficient and targeted interventions designed to rehabilitate impairments of executive and attentional functions. Furthermore, such interventions may be highly beneficial to the field of cognitive aging.  

Age related cognitive change is often highly associated with deficiencies in working memory and perceptual/processing speed, the very functions most often shown to be improvable through training.

Search the database of Resaearch Project

Faculty
Funding Source
Discipline
Principal Investigator

Research Projects

Research Projects 01-09-2016

Future is Uncertain

Imagine a world where everything you have planned, would happen for certain. Moreover, if all the future events were positive, it would be a perfect world. Unfortunately in real life...

Read more

Research Projects 08-08-2016

Attitudinal Influences on Moral Judgments

Moral judgments and impressions are tremendously important. In extreme situations they can decide about life or death, for example convicted murderers perceived as untrustworthy (based on their appearance) are more...

Read more

Research Projects 21-07-2016

A History of Rwanda

Most people have heard about the Rwanda genocide. However, Rwanda’s history as a country goes back to the 19th century. Prior to Belgian colonisation, the current territory of Rwanda had...

Read more

Research Projects 09-06-2016

Peer Groups and Migration

The school-to-work transition is not a one-time event in the lives of young people. Rather, it is a phase that may last a few years and may include several career...

Read more

Research Projects 11-05-2016

Law on Higher Education 2.0 - Guidelines for Higher Education System i…

The team of lawyers from SWPS University, under the leadership of Professor Hubert Izdebski, will take an active role in preparing the guidelines for the new Law on Higher Education...

Read more

Research Projects 09-05-2016

The influence of psychological knowledge on the decision-making proces…

Witness testimony is a crucial element of the criminal justice system. However, memory is often false and perception distorted. Yet the testimony based on such imperfect data may change a...

Read more

Research Projects 09-09-2015

DESMOPSI System

Nowadays, the understanding of the need for psychological therapy in difficult or traumatic situations and the social acceptance of psychological intervention is growing. At the same time, in Poland alone...

Read more

Research Projects 21-08-2015

DATABASE OF EMOTIONAL MOVIES and its Application in Temperamental Stud…

An attempt to understand emotional responses and a nature of determined temperament dates back to the Ancient Greece. Modern science applies many research methods for studies of emotional behaviors, including...

Read more

Research Projects 21-08-2015

Cognitive and motivational determinants of sympathetic magic in close …

Does separation with a loved-one change the way we perceive mementos (e.g. souvenirs, clothes, and photographs) associated with the relationship? The research project conducted by psychologists from the Sopot Campus...

Read more

Research Projects 13-08-2015

Turning depressed mood into a joke - is it beneficial?

The application of emotion regulation skills in prevention of depression has been attempted repeatedly, without much success so far. Researchers from SWPS University will investigate the effects of humor, one...

Read more

Research Projects 17-02-2015

In Charge or in Control?

Having power over others or being subjected to power exercised by others is almost an everyday experience for large segments of the society. Therefore, power relationships have broad social consequences...

Read more

Research Projects 09-12-2014

Political Knowledge in Poland

The aim of the project is to investigate political knowledge in Poland, and its importance for the Polish political system. We want to check how knowledgeable/ignorant Poles are about politics...

Read more

Research Projects 09-12-2014

Plato's Conception of Justice from the Perspective of the Contemporary…

The project, though about Plato, relates to one of the fundamental problems of contemporary civilisation: are human rights, which are based in human dignity, truly universal in space and time?...

Read more

Research Projects 15-05-2014

Trajectories of Coping with Illness

The stress of coping with a serious or chronic illness impacts not only the patient, but also their family. The family worries about their loved one and must juggle their...

Read more

Research Projects 28-03-2014

Seeing is believing? Suggestion and misinformation in the video transm…

The objective of the project is to study how video images and messages are perceived and assessed by viewers. During the project, the researchers will study the reactions of viewers...

Read more

Research Projects 07-01-2014

E-COMPARED European Comparative Effectiveness Research on Internet-bas…

In 2010, 30 million Europeans were affected by depression and the number continues to grow. Half of the depression sufferers requiring mental care lack access to care services. Moreover, they...

Read more

Research Projects 09-09-2013

Social distortion mechanisms in comparative judgments. Alternative exp…

Social distortions in comparative judgments may lead to the categorization of people and divisions and thus to depreciation of their values. The research project relates to the phenomenon known as...

Read more

Research Projects 09-09-2013

The role of cognitive limitations in predecisional information process…

The project focuses on the impact of cognitive limitations on decision making. This impact is obvious in everyday decision-making, which we often do under time pressure or stress. The current...

Read more

Research Projects 09-09-2013

The Expertise Bias: its psychological mechanisms, sources and conseque…

Consumers make decisions related to investing money, taking bank loans or buying insurance policies. They often consult their choices with financial experts. In the present project we carry out experiments...

Read more

Research Projects 11-03-2013

To train or to play? A comparison of traditional and gamified training…

The aim of the project is to better understand the processes undergoing during a traditional cognitive training and to compare them with analogous processes happening during a modern method of...

Read more

Research Projects 19-10-2012

Attentional bias modification and depressive disorders

It is estimated that almost 10 percent of general population suffers from depression, but not everyone has access to effective treatments. Nowadays, depression is treated primarily with pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy...

Read more

Research Projects 21-08-2012

Psychological and Biological sources of risk aversion

Are men bigger risk takers than women? The research project, led by Szymon Wichary, Ph.D., provides data on personal differences and their impact risk taking and risk aversion. Combining data...

Read more

Research Projects 01-12-2011

A typology of the relations between non-governmental organizations in …

A close working relationship between NGOs, including knowledge and best practice sharing as well as common planning and project development, supports the growth of the third sector in economy. A...

Read more